Because Sometimes Crazy Advice Is the Best Advice

I do a lot of things wrong as a parent. Some days, I am pretty sure I do everything wrong. Sporadically though, I do a few things that turn out okay.

What constantly amazes me is how my best laid plans fall all the way apart.  I try so hard to do the proper thing to get the proper result, and it just doesn’t work.  My pride takes a beating.

Conversely, I do something tragically wrong, and God completely redeems the situation. Everything turns out sunshine and roses.

I have a feeling this is by design.

I try to remind myself of this every time I start to worry about disciplining my preschoolers the right way, or I try to pick the perfect homeschool  curriculum, or my children (or I myself) embarrass me publically.

I also remind myself of this when I get advice from other moms.  Some advice might seem spectacular, but when I attempt to follow it, I crash and burn.   Other advice might seem crazy, but ends up being awesome. That’s my favorite kind of advice.

In fact recently, I received some advice that I was sure I would never ever endeavor.  A dear family friend who has raised 4 amazing kids (all adults now) shared some wisdom with me when I asked her how to handle a particular discipline issue.  I confessed to her that my 3 year old and 5 year old were constantly hitting and pushing each other and generally making each other miserable.  She, in a very sincere and serious voice, advised me that I should teach them the “golden rule:” When one child hits the other, I should supervise while having the other child hit the first offender back.

What??!!  That’s just crazy!  I’m sorry, but that just sounded demented to me.

Well, a few days later, I was at my wits end, so I gave it a whirl.  And guess what? It wasn’t nearly the disaster I thought it would be.  I’ve actually continued with it for a few weeks now, and it’s working fairly well.  We’re having far fewer physical encounters.  Most shockingly, the kids really do not often take justice into their own hands.  They usually come to me and ask if they should hit (or push or poke) the offender back.  Seriously!  And they don’t seem to enjoy giving the payback–well, at least not much.

I am dumbfounded!

Now keep in mind, you might undertake this same advice with no success.  But then again, you never know.

Ergo, in response to this totally unexpected triumph, I am going to start an advice column.  I’m calling it “Dear Pooky:  Unorthodox Parenting Advice from a Mother of 5.”  I will dedicate the occasional blog post to sharing some pretty wacky advice—all derived from nutty things I’ve done as a parent that have actually turned out pretty well.

Be on the lookout for the first “Dear Pooky” post.  It’s coming soon.

Prepare to be aghast.  Prepare to be dismayed.  Prepare to maybe even be amazed.  Because sometimes crazy advice is the best advice.

5 thoughts on “Because Sometimes Crazy Advice Is the Best Advice

  1. Megan, we too struggle with siblings being unkind to each other. I loathe it!! However, I struggle with the approach. Is it teaching my kid to be like Jesus? What happened to the ol' is someone smacks one cheek offer the other? I would love to stop this behavior in my home.

  2. I'm with you, Tracy. That's exactly why I thought it was crazy advice. I'm still not convinced it the right thing to do, just that the results are not as expected. In my particular case, I am dealing with preschoolers, and justice seems to be an easier lesson to grasp. Maybe we're starting with the law: "an eye for an eye." And we'll graduate to grace: "turn the other cheek."

  3. Also, I do teach them not to hit in the first place. But maybe there is a little value in learning there is a real world consequence. We do talk about how if they hit someone in "the real world," they will very likely get hit back.

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.